Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Counter argument: American sites should try supporting a language other than English.

Many EU sites have multiple languages sorted into different flags up at the top of the page. Ours do not.



Using flags for language isn't really a great pattern. It kind of works if you only support a few languages, but when you support a lot you get into tough issues where many flags relate to a single language and many languages relate to a single flag.

http://www.flagsarenotlanguages.com/blog/why-flags-do-not-re...


Like most things, this is ordinarily not done when the economics do not appear to support doing it.


In the US, the local, state, and international language is the same thing.


There are thousands of languages the choice of languages to support logically ought to come from a cost benefit analysis of supporting a given tongue. European institutions are pretty much always going to be dealing with people that speak a wide variety of languages. Within the US we are talking about a market of 300 million wherein most individuals speak English as a first language or in addition to their primary language.

Doing business outside the US would almost certainly involve a lot more work than translating the website. This doesn't mean its a bad idea but its certainly a complicated decision.


Many countries have multiple languages (or scripts) unique to them. India, Spain, China are amongst these. You could use the Taiwanese/ROC flag for traditional chinese but you'd anger mainland China.


Please, don't use flags unless you want to bring politics into it.


its a visual representation of a language that often conveys information to people whom speak an unknown tongue. Given an array of choices people may be able to pick out the graphic quicker.


Would you like to not be allowed to do business in China? All you have to do is use the flag of the Republic of China to indicate traditional Chinese.

Use names of languages, localized into those languages, for the selection. Or if you must save space, use two-letter language codes.


> its a visual representation of a language

No it's not. It's a visual representation of a country, state or region, at best.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: