Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So Apple should stick to en even older standard (SMS/MMS)?

All that Google is asking is for the fallback to be at least in the current century, is that too much to ask.



Isn’t that the safest fallback, if you know they aren’t using iMessage? The other phone could be a phone that can’t accept RCS or iMessage.


Fallbacks can be layered. For a company that claims go all-out for its consumers privacy, using SMS as the default fallback in the 21st century is pretty sus.


There’s over a dozen different versions of RCS, hand who knows which carrier supports which parts. It’d be more fall-through (the cracks) than fall back.


Yes it seems that RCS is actually not a real fallback, it is a request to support yet another modern(ish) system.


I personally think they should adopt something brand new and not evil. I'm not saying that RCS is evil, but from what I can tell, while it has federation, Google seems to be gaining a monopoly on RCS (sorry, I don't remember what article I read that in). My pick would be something like Matrix or even XMPP to make sure that there's a definite standard that is federated by design; however, you'd have to trust your carrier/software to not dump your messages onto Google's server instead of using a different server.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: